The Art of Tarot Interpretation: Are There Right and Wrong Readings?
Between traditional symbolism, intuition, and the question of what a Tarot card can actually tell us.
Two people look at the same Tarot card.
One sees an approaching upheaval. Another recognizes an inner conflict that has existed for a long time. A third interprets the card as pointing toward a decision that has so far been avoided.
Which of them is right?
This question touches upon one of the most fascinating problems in Tarot interpretation. Although the cards have inherited meanings, they cannot be translated like words in an ordinary dictionary.
Their imagery is multilayered. Their interpretation changes according to the question being asked, their position within a spread, and the cards surrounding them.
But does this openness mean that every interpretation is equally valid?
Or are there criteria that allow us to distinguish a convincing interpretation from an arbitrary claim?
The answer lies neither in one universally binding meaning for each card nor in unlimited freedom of interpretation. It lies in the reasoned relationship between symbol, context, and interpretation.
1. Why Tarot Cards Do Not Contain Definitive Answers
Tarot cards are images, not fixed statements.
A card depicts a scene, a figure, or a symbolic arrangement. Its meaning emerges only when we interpret that representation.
Consider the High Priestess.
In the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot, she sits between two pillars, holds a scroll in her lap, and gazes calmly toward the viewer.
In Western esoteric tradition, she is frequently associated with intuition, hidden knowledge, stillness, and mystery.
Yet none of these meanings is explicitly stated on the card.
The associations emerge from inherited symbolism, historical traditions of interpretation, and the impressions evoked by the image.
In one reading, the High Priestess might therefore suggest the need for patient observation. In another, she might raise questions about unspoken expectations.
Both interpretations may be meaningful within their respective contexts.
This does not, however, mean that the card actually reveals a hidden event or provides reliable access to another person’s thoughts.
Here, we must distinguish between two questions:
What can reasonably be interpreted from a symbol? And what can actually be known about reality?
This distinction forms the foundation of responsible Tarot interpretation.
2. Traditional Card Meanings: A Shared Foundation
Tarot is not a system whose meanings every reader must invent entirely from scratch.
Different traditions of interpretation have developed over the centuries.
Among the most influential today are the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot, the Thoth Tarot, and the various traditions associated with the Tarot de Marseille.
These systems share certain historical foundations but differ in their imagery and esoteric correspondences.
In the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot, for example, the Ten of Cups is often associated with emotional fulfilment, family unity, and an ideal of harmonious relationships.
The Three of Swords depicts a heart pierced by swords and is traditionally linked to pain, disappointment, or separation.
The Magician frequently represents initiative, the ability to act, and the conscious use of available skills.
Such meanings provide an inherited framework for interpretation.
They allow a reading to be explained and compared with other interpretations.
Yet traditional meanings are not immutable laws of nature.
They developed historically, were shaped by particular authors, and sometimes differ considerably between Tarot systems.
Anyone who wishes to understand Tarot seriously should therefore do more than memorize lists of meanings. They should also ask where those meanings came from and why particular images became associated with particular ideas.
3. How Context Changes Interpretation
Within a Tarot spread, a card acquires its particular significance through the context in which it appears.
This includes the question being asked, its position within the spread, neighbouring cards, and the circumstances of the person seeking the reading.
Consider the Sun, card XIX of the Major Arcana.
It is traditionally associated with vitality, clarity, joy, and success.
But what might it mean in different positions?
The Sun as the Present Situation
In a question about personal development, it might symbolically suggest self-confidence, a period of greater clarity, or the desire for openness.
The Sun as a Challenge
When it appears in a position specifically representing difficulties, its positive symbolism may take on a different emphasis.
Perhaps the issue concerns excessive expectations, a desire for recognition, or difficulty acknowledging uncomfortable aspects of a situation.
The Sun as a Possible Development
In this position, it might represent the hope of achieving clarity, more open communication, or a desirable goal.
None of these interpretations follows inevitably from the card.
They are possibilities that must be justified by their particular context.
It is also essential to ask whether an interpretation genuinely relates to the situation or has simply been phrased so generally that it could apply to almost anyone.
Context makes an interpretation more specific. It does not automatically make it true.
4. Intuition and Knowledge: Two Different Ways of Understanding?
Tarot practice often distinguishes between traditional and intuitive interpretation.
The traditional approach draws on inherited card meanings, symbols, spreads, and, where appropriate, astrological or Kabbalistic correspondences.
The intuitive approach places greater emphasis on spontaneous impressions, personal associations, and the immediate effect of a card’s imagery.
Both approaches can be combined.
However, intuition should not be mistaken for an infallible source of knowledge.
An experienced Tarot reader may recognize connections between images and questions without being consciously aware of every intermediate step in their reasoning.
Such impressions may arise from experience, pattern recognition, and years of engagement with symbolism.
But they can also be influenced by expectations, prejudices, or the reader’s own emotional state.
It is therefore sensible to regard intuitive impressions initially as possible interpretations.
A spontaneous insight may open an interesting line of questioning. It is not, however, proof that a particular assumption is correct.
Traditional symbolism provides an important point of reference here.
It allows intuitive impressions to be compared with established meanings and helps determine whether an interpretation remains coherent within the system being used.
Intuition can enrich an interpretation. Critical reflection helps determine whether it is convincing.
5. When Does a Tarot Interpretation Become Arbitrary?
If cards can have several meanings, the question of interpretative boundaries inevitably arises.
Consider the High Priestess once again.
An interpretation connecting her with stillness, inner awareness, or the experience of uncertainty can be reasonably derived from her imagery and inherited meanings.
But if a reader claims, solely on the basis of this card, that a particular person is concealing an act of deception, they have gone considerably further.
They have transformed a symbolic motif into a specific factual claim for which the card provides no verifiable evidence.
The same applies to Death, card XIII of the Major Arcana.
In many modern Tarot traditions, this card is associated with endings, transitions, and transformation.
To conclude directly that someone’s death is approaching would not only be unfounded but could also cause considerable fear.
Responsible interpretation must therefore distinguish between what a symbol may suggest and what can legitimately be established as fact.
Four Criteria for a Reasoned Interpretation
1. Symbolic Connection
Can the interpretation be justified through the card’s imagery or an identifiable interpretative tradition?
2. Relevance to the Question
Does the interpretation have a recognizable connection to the person’s concern, or has an arbitrary meaning been introduced?
3. Internal Coherence
Does the interpretation fit the surrounding cards and the structure of the spread without simply ignoring obvious contradictions?
4. Appropriate Restraint
Is there a clear distinction between a symbolic possibility, a personal assumption, and a verifiable factual claim?
These criteria do not guarantee an objectively correct interpretation.
They do, however, help make interpretations more transparent and limit arbitrary assertions.
6. When Several Interpretations Are Possible at Once
One characteristic of symbolic systems is that an image can allow several meanings without those meanings necessarily excluding one another.
Consider the Eight of Cups in the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot.
It depicts a figure leaving behind a row of cups and setting out into a nighttime landscape.
Traditional interpretations often associate this image with departure, withdrawal, or the search for something beyond one’s present circumstances.
In a career-related question, it might suggest dissatisfaction with familiar work.
In a relationship question, the card might symbolize a desire for distance.
In a question about personal development, it could encourage reflection on changing values and priorities.
These interpretations differ, but they share a common visual motif.
The card is not being reinterpreted at random. Rather, an inherited symbolic structure is being applied to different areas of life.
This reveals something distinctive about the way Tarot works.
The aim is not always to discover one single meaning.
Sometimes the real task is to recognize several possible interpretations and examine which of them is useful and reasonably justified in relation to the question at hand.
7. The Danger of Confirmation Bias
A Tarot interpretation may seem convincing at the moment of a reading.
But how can we later determine whether it was actually accurate?
Here, we encounter a fundamental problem of human perception.
We tend to pay greater attention to information that confirms our existing expectations. Contradictory evidence is more easily overlooked or reinterpreted afterward.
This phenomenon is known as confirmation bias.
In Tarot readings, it can cause a statement that was initially vague to appear remarkably precise in hindsight.
Suppose a card is interpreted as indicating an approaching change.
A few weeks later, the person changes jobs.
The interpretation seems to have been confirmed.
But what if, instead, they had ended a relationship, taken a journey, or made an important personal decision?
These events might also have been interpreted as changes.
The broader a statement is, the more different events can subsequently be connected to it.
For this reason, a distinction should be made between general symbolic reflection and a specific prediction.
Anyone wishing to examine their own interpretative practice critically can document readings, including the date, the original question, and the interpretation given at the time.
It is particularly important not to alter those statements retrospectively.
A Tarot journal can therefore serve not only as a record of personal experiences but also as a means of recognizing the limitations of one’s interpretations.
8. Can an Interpretation Be Meaningful Even When It Is Inaccurate?
This question brings us to another important distinction.
An interpretation can hold personal significance without accurately describing external facts.
Imagine that the Four of Pentacles appears in a reading.
The reader interprets it as suggesting a fear of losing something familiar.
The person receiving the reading does not initially recognize themselves in this description.
During the conversation, however, another question emerges: What does security actually mean to them?
This may lead to a meaningful exploration of personal values, even though the original interpretation was not accurate.
The potential value of the reading then lies not in confirming some hidden truth.
It lies in the fact that a symbol inspired a thought that had not previously been considered.
This is a different kind of significance.
It should not be confused with a successful prediction or an objectively correct diagnosis.
Recognizing this distinction makes it possible to approach Tarot as a symbolic tool for reflection without overlooking its limitations.
9. The Responsibility of the Tarot Reader
The question of right and wrong interpretations concerns more than the method itself.
It also concerns responsibility toward the person seeking guidance.
Someone who approaches a Tarot reader with a personal question may be experiencing a period of uncertainty.
Perhaps the concern involves relationships, career changes, or difficult decisions.
In such circumstances, even cautiously worded statements can have a considerable impact.
An interpretation should therefore never be presented as true merely because it sounds impressive or evokes strong emotions.
Nor should a Tarot reader insist that someone must accept an interpretation because the cards have supposedly revealed an uncomfortable truth.
An interpretation may be questioned.
It may seem inappropriate.
And it may be rejected.
This does not mean that every rejection automatically proves an interpretation false.
It simply means that a Tarot reader should not claim privileged access to another person’s inner life or future.
Responsible Tarot guidance creates a dialogue. It does not demand unquestioning belief.
10. How to Improve Your Own Tarot Interpretation Skills
Anyone wishing to learn Tarot or deepen their existing skills can benefit from several fundamental principles.
Become Familiar with the Visual Language
Do not rely exclusively on lists of keywords.
Study the images, figures, colours, objects, and spatial relationships depicted on the cards.
Ask yourself which elements are actually visible and which meanings you are adding through interpretation.
Distinguish Between Different Tarot Traditions
Not every card uses the same imagery in every deck.
The Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot, Thoth Tarot, and Tarot de Marseille follow different artistic and esoteric concepts.
An interpretation becomes easier to understand and justify when you know which system you are using.
Formulate Your Question as Clearly as Possible
A vague question opens almost unlimited possibilities for interpretation.
A specific but open-ended question, by contrast, makes it easier to relate the cards to a recognizable context.
Instead of asking, “What will become of my life?”, you might ask, “Which aspects of my current career situation should I examine more closely?”
Remain Open to Multiple Interpretations
Your first association is not necessarily the most convincing.
Consider whether the imagery allows other readings, and distinguish between plausible possibilities and far-fetched claims.
Document Your Readings
Record the original question, the cards drawn, their positions, and your interpretation.
When comparing them with later events, also record which statements proved inaccurate or were too vague to be meaningfully evaluated.
Recognize the Limitations of the Method
Tarot cannot replace medical diagnoses, legal advice, or professional financial guidance.
Claims about another person’s secret intentions or specific future events should not be presented as established knowledge.
These limitations do not prevent meaningful engagement with the cards.
Instead, they provide a responsible framework for it.
11. My Approach: Interpretation Is Not the Same as Knowledge
In my work with Tarot and Lenormand, I have long been interested in the question of how symbolic images acquire personal meaning.
A card has a particular visual form and a historically developed tradition of interpretation.
Yet a specific interpretation emerges only when the card is connected to a question.
Several factors contribute to this process: experience, knowledge of symbolism, personal associations, intuition, and the context of the conversation.
This makes Tarot reading a demanding interpretative practice.
It does not, however, mean that every statement arising from such a practice automatically constitutes knowledge about reality.
For me, one distinction is therefore essential:
An interpretation is initially a proposal to understand something in a particular way. Whether it leads to well-founded knowledge is a separate question.
This approach requires openness in both directions.
We should not dismiss unusual ideas merely because they emerge from symbolic reflection.
But neither should we regard them as true simply because they move us emotionally or seem surprisingly accurate.
Between these two possibilities lies the space in which careful Tarot interpretation can take place.
12. So, Are There Right and Wrong Tarot Interpretations?
The answer depends on what we mean by right and wrong.
Historically and within a particular system, an interpretation may be more or less well-founded. It may agree with an established tradition or contradict it.
Symbolically, an interpretation may be coherent, multilayered, and appropriate to the context — or arbitrary and contradictory.
Personally, it may inspire new thoughts even without describing an objective truth.
As a factual claim, however, it must be measured against verifiable information. A convincing symbolic interpretation cannot replace evidence.
These four levels should not be confused.
The fact that a card can be interpreted in different ways does not mean that every statement made about it is equally justified.
And the fact that an interpretation feels personally meaningful does not prove that it has revealed a hidden reality.
The art of Tarot interpretation does not lie in extracting a final truth from every card. It lies in distinguishing between what a symbol suggests, what we recognize within it, and what we actually know.
When a Card's Meaning Becomes a Personal Exploration
Perhaps you have experienced how the same Tarot card seems to take on a different meaning in different circumstances.
Perhaps a particular card continues to fascinate you, or you would like to understand why different Tarot readers sometimes arrive at different interpretations.
A personal Tarot reading can provide a setting in which the symbolism of the cards is explored in relation to your specific question.
The aim is not to force an unchanging answer.
It is to examine possible meanings carefully, consider their connections, and leave room for your own judgment.
If you would like to explore this approach to Tarot interpretation, we can examine your personal question together.
ALARIK TAROT
TAROT & SYMBOLIC INSIGHT
Beyond the Visible. Into the Meaning.
Personal Tarot & Lenormand Readings, Astrology and Mystical Exploration
Request a Personal Reading
Legal Information
Tarot and astrology readings offer symbolic interpretation and personal reflection. They are not a substitute for professional medical, psychological, legal or financial advice.
© 2026 Alarik Tarot · All rights reserved.
